I generally heart Oprah.
Giving away free cars, new homes, and yummy Nate Berkus. Seriously, he.is.edible.
You can't beat it, really.
But when she starts offering her "feelings" about having kids and being a working vs. stay-at-home mother, then I start to roll my eyes.
Okay. I sort of curse at the screen.
Did you catch the show on Tuesday? Elizabeth Vargas was on talking about her decision to leave World News Tonight and return to 20/20. And interwoven in her story were tales of guilt, sadness, and loss.
She got hammered by the public. "It's a step backwards for women."
Why? She still works 12 hour days. She just isn't traveling to Iraq.
I digress.
Then a bunch of stay-at-home-moms and work-out-of-home moms pseudo-battled it out. "I wish I had spent more time on me" said a SAHM. "I wish I had more time with my kids" replied a WOHM. And then Oprah piped in about watching Gail raise her kids and then she lost me.
I rarely feel that people cannot have some level of empathy if they have not experienced something themselves. As a therapist, much of what I did was based on empathy -- not personal experience. You just can't have (and many times, you don't want to have) every experience in life. That doesn't mean you cannot empathize and imagine how it might feel.
But when it comes to motherhood, particularly the decision of working and staying home, I have to say that for the most part (at least when it comes to this issue and labor) YOU HAVE TO BE THERE.
For me, I went back to work part-time for the first year of my daughter's life. I was extremely fortunate in that I took her to work with me. But quite frankly, my mind was always on her. I'd be teaching a class, and in my head I'd be wondering if she was hungry, or tired, or screaming her fool-head off.
But even after that year ended, I still did some work outside the home thanks to a trusty sitter. And I realized that I needed to have some type of "work" to sustain me. And I needed to make money.
And that was me.
I have few opinions about this argument, only that for many women, staying-at-home is just not an option. Perhaps financially, but more importantly for their own sanity. IT IS HARD. IT IS NOT FUN. And not everyone is good at it.
My only opinion comes when women are unable to do what they want -- to work part-time and be home. To live their dream. To "have it all."
But then, it's not my opinion to share with that mom. It's my opinion to share with our society - our world - that doesn't value mothering.
Maybe Oprah might have spent more time talking about making a change, as opposed to just rehashing an old argument that never got us anywhere in the first place.
What about you? How did you make the decision to stay home, work, etc? Any judgments (your own or from other people)?
--
Congrats to Carolyn (correct date and length) and Sandy (correct weight and length)! You are both winners in my baby pool. I know many of you had correct weight/length/date only, however, I figured I'd go with the folks who had 2 or more right. Email me with your address and I'll send you off a lovely prize.
Recent Comments